Evelyn Brodie

Shamanic, Reiki & Craniosacral Healing Rottingdean, Brighton, East Sussex

Healing vs curing

One of the main differences between Western medicine and integrated healthcare is the focus in the former on curing or at least managing symptoms rather than healing the causes underlying the symptoms. An obvious and all too frequent example is depression. GPs frequently hand out anti-depressants to patients without also giving them appropriate therapy or social care to deal with the underlying cause of their depression. This may help patients to get out of bed in the morning and go to work/school/take care of their children etc, apparently curing the symptoms, which can be a useful short term strategy, but it can lead to a life of addiction (often with side effects from the medications) if it’s not accompanied by finding out why people are depressed and helping to deal with that underlying cause.

Johann Hari wrote a wonderful book called Lost Connections, which investigates the anti-depressant industry and then considers alternative treatments, which deal with the causes of the depression. This of course gets us deep into social policy and the fact that is it NORMAL to be anxious or depressed if one has no hope, doing a job you hate to feed your family, to live in terrible housing in an area where you are abused physically or emotionally whenever you leave, or where you feel chronically unsafe.

Therapists and their clients cannot always deal with these underlying social causes much as they might wish for systemic change or additional financial resources. But no matter what is happening around you, much of which you cannot control, the one thing you can control is how you react to it, which is called resilience. And often people do have more choices available than they may initially believe or perceive. But it is difficult to truly heal something that is not even seen or acknowledged, which is why the work needs to be done in the shadows, the trauma, the shit! As Thomas Hubl, an expert in Collective Trauma notes, a lot of what is going wrong in the world right now is the result of the unacknowledged and hence unresolved trauma of the past.

Caroline Myss writes, 'A 'cure' occurs when one has successfully controlled or abated the physical progression of an illness. Curing a physical illness, however, does not necessarily mean that the emotional and psychological stresses that were a part of the illness were also alleviated. In this case it is highly possible, and often probable, that an illness will recur.

'The process of curing is passive; that is the patient is inclined to give his or her authority over to the physician and prescribed treatment instead of actively challenging the illness and reclaiming health. Healing, on the other hand, is an active and internal process that includes investigating one's attitudes, memories, and beliefs with the desire to release all negative patterns that prevent one's full emotional and spiritual recovery.'

I am always working for healing, not just curing. And if one believes in the continuation of a spirit/soul/consciousness beyond the end of the physical body, then curing the physical body may indeed not be possible, but deep healing of the soul can take place before death so that there is less ‘baggage’ carried over into the next lifetime or realm. Big subjects on which I will say more later!

 


Terms of Use

© Evelyn Brodie powered by WebHealer

Terms of Use

Access to and use of this site is provided by Evelyn M Brodie subject to the following terms:

1. By using this website you agree to be legally bound by these terms, which shall take effect immediately on your first use of this website. If you do not agree to be legally bound by all the following terms please do not access and/or use this website. Your continued use of this website after changes are posted means you agree to be legally bound by these terms as updated and/or amended.


Intellectual Property and copyright

2. All rights, including copyright, in this website and its contents, are owned by Evelyn Brodie. In accessing this website, you agree that you will access the contents solely for your own private use and not for any commercial or public use, distribution or publication. You may not copy, reproduce, republish, download, post, broadcast, transmit, make available to the public, or otherwise use this website content in any way except for your own personal, non-commercial use.


Use of the Website

3. You agree not to adapt, alter or create a derivative work from any of the material contained in this site or use it for any other purpose other than for your personal non-commercial use. You agree to use this site only for lawful purposes, and in a manner that does not infringe the rights of, or restrict or inhibit the use and enjoyment of this site by any third party. Such restriction or inhibition includes, without limitation, conduct which is unlawful, or which may harass or cause distress or inconvenience to any person and the transmission of obscene or offensive content or disruption of normal flow of dialogue within this site.